| Emerging
talent
The CitiEquity Emerging Markets
Fund looks to have some robust credentials. Nigel Davies talks to
fund manager Aquico Wen about the fund’s prospects
As China and
other Asian nations strive to become the manufacturing powerhouses
of the East and companies flourish, emerging markets are looking
very attractive. Russia and Brazil are also both actively seeking
to stabilise their economies and have performed well recently. Bringing
together all the benefits that these markets can offer while allaying
investors fears of volatility is a hard task, but one that Aquico
Wen, portfolio manager of the Citi Equity Emerging Markets Fund,
aims to achieve.
The fund was rebranded and launched in 2001 and now can be described
as a medium-sized fund standing at $266.9m. It is domiciled in Luxembourg
and aims to provide long-term growth through investing in equities
across a diversified range of emerging markets and industries. The
main target is to outperform the MSCI Emerging Markets Free Net
Index by 4 per cent annually.
As the fund was only recently incepted performance is hard to evaluate,
but so far this year it has produced pleasing returns of 33.08 per
cent against the benchmark of 31.34 per cent. Wen is confident that
the aim of 4 per cent is well within reach by year end. The fund
has a standard deviation of 26 per cent.
Citi does not set a minimum investment for the fund but rather a
sum is negotiated with the distributor. The base currency for the
fund is US dollars though certain share classes are available in
EUR as well. A subscription fee of up to 5 per cent is levied and
there is also an annual management fee of up to 2 per cent.
What also stands out when investigating this fund is how rigid the
investment philosophy and stock selection process are, which is
something comforting to investors wishing to enter in to emerging
markets. Breakdown of the fund in the bank’s literature is
very easy to get to grips with and the exposure to countries and
sectors is clearly outlined. This is something that the bank likes
to highlight as it is felt by Citi that this is a good fund for
investors to start off in in this asset class.
The team running
the fund is also well equipped with three portfolio managers covering
specific regions (Asia, Latin America and EMEA). Wen has responsibility
for Latin America and manages to travel there around twice a year
to make company visits. He is also helped by 18 analysts who are
dedicated to emerging markets. The fund itself has two country strategists
who aim to try and anticipate changes in country risk.
This forms one of the keys of the investment philosophy employed
by Wen, alongside valuation and seeking out surprises which could
impact stock prices. Detailed research is carried out on every company
selected with the hope of avoiding following the market in buying
a stock without fully comprehending company fundamentals.
Wen says: “The market research that we carry out covers a
lot of the risk element of the fund. We focus on company valuations
and the rating given to them by our analysts, but also look to country
assessments of political and economical risk. The fund is also very
diversified in terms of the companies in the portfolio which maintains
a higher level of security from risk.”
The fund works to a strict Dividend Discount Model which seeks to
find a company’s true value based on its growth rates, risk
factors and cashflows. Deviations from the fair value formulated
indicate to the team under or overvaluation which can then be corrected
over a period of time.
The rigid investment
process is praised by Kevin Morgan, managing director of IFA EZI
UK. “The fund does really well in quantifying risk and this
is something of a novel idea which you don’t often see with
many funds. The fact that it’s Citi gives comfort, too, as
you’re not going to get a bigger firm to manage your assets.
It’s obviously a highly thought of fund if S&P have given
it an AA fund management rating.”
There are currently 121 holdings in the portfolio spread across
sectors and regions, though the fund is overweight in Asia. Wen
says: “A few months ago we changed our position and are now
aggressively overweight in Asia. We saw that companies were undervalued
at the time of the SARS crisis and changed our outlook while maintaining
a 1-3 year investment horizon for all stocks. Companies in the region
are now more focused on returns and they are cheaper than any other
asset class. While valuation levels were stretched in the 1990’s
there are now great opportunities to be had.”
Korean companies occupy the biggest percentage of the portfolio
at 22.36 per cent while Taiwan is also in favour with 15.11 per
cent and a strong position for South Africa at 11.80 per cent is
also evident.
Wen explains
why Korea holds such a large chunk of the portfolio. “Korea’s
technology sector has grown considerable and valuations are extremely
attractive. It is currently the lowest cost producer in Asia and
we see many companies trading at a discount. Although the country
does grab the headlines for political reasons we don’t see
a risk of conflict as none of the surrounding countries would like
to see this.”
The fund also has several big name firms among its top holdings.
Samsung Electronic accounts for a large 8.2 per cent of the portfolio
and South African gold mining firm Anglo American makes up 3 per
cent. Although there is now an underweight position to Latin America,
Petrol Brasileiros and Telefonos de Mexico also figure in the top
ten stocks.
Though the fund has plenty of positives it does receive some criticism,
in particular for its fees. Charles Ansdell, industry commentator,
says: “It is quite difficult to assess as it has not been
around for very long, but at the moment I wouldn’t say it’s
a stunner.
The charges are high in comparison to most UK funds and it has quite
a defensive portfolio. It could be more aggressive and I wonder
if you may be better off going for a tracker fund. That way if you
had an exchange traded fund you could track an emerging markets
index without having to pay for any management fees and there is
also less risk involved.”
Morgan adds: “The fees are high and I think this fund would
have to fulfil its objective of outperforming the market by 4 per
cent to make it worthwhile and this seems quite brave. I do feel
that it’s a problem that you can’t use sterling to enter
the fund as there is more of a currency risk there. It doesn’t
smack you between the eyes and make you think ‘what a cracker’,
but it has done relatively well performance wise and it is very
actively managed.”
The foundations are in place for this fund to be a success and Wen
believes that this fund will make its targets. “Emerging markets
have been extremely positive as an asset class this year and I am
confident that we will achieve four per cent above the benchmark
by year end. The fund has already shown a high level of consistency
in its performance.”
|